Initially the strategy was good. Later on I guess the manager took a break and didn't anything for almost a year and mails which were sent daily became weekly and later once in a fortnight.

Never given 5 stars before but this system deserves it. The higher subscription cost is a big increase but returns to date have been outstanding and warrant the extra expenditure.

Excellent trading strategy!

Looks like there is no definitive strategy and does not adapt to market conditions.

Stay away from it. He will blow the account sooner or later. No risk control at all, he just hopes for the run to continue forever. No logic in his entries or exits, so no strategy at all in reality.

Strategy direction seems perfect. I subscribed since mid Nov 2025. Price increased from 185 USD/month to 495 USD/month. Such a massive price rise is not justified. It is noted that stop loss is placed at the opening of market and it hits/executed most of the time and booked the loss. but after one hour it reversed and price goes up. If stop loss order placed after 1 hour of market open then profit erosion can be prevented.

Good strategy manager with a systematic approach, and taking measured risk. The recent silver trade wasn't worth the risk/reward and I would never take it personally, but I'm comfortable with the resulting drawdown from a few bad trades as I trust overwhelming majority will be good ones long term. The only downside is the deficiencies of the collective2 system with respect to option strategies, and the inability to deal with even simple spreads. The strategy is actually more profitable if executed as proper spreads like the strategy manager intended, Size the account at least at minimum, or even higher - as collective2 systems typically end up putting in short leg of the spread first (at least on some part of the order) and create unnecessary margin errors. The strategy itself never uses more than a few thousand dollars of margin, but even a 35k account struggles with margin warnings due to the deficient collective2 order system for option spreads - which they seem not willing to improve (there are >10 year old threads in the forum complaining about this with no apparent progress!)

It seem like a good strategy but very expensive so it eats up most of the profit. I'm still unprofitable due to the timing of when I activated and went live plus the strategy fee. I am currently looking for a more affordable strategy so I can be profitable.

Feels like we have bought high sold low, over and over and over.

Suddenly strategy plan is revised from 185 to 495 $.

Strategy is very easy to follow. No need to sign up for AutoTrader. Just set up a separate email account just for this strategy and enable audible alert. You will have sufficient time to make the trade close to the authors traded price. Usually holds four or five ETFs at one time

I give a neutral of 3 stars rating here. The strategy tries to get close to a 100% winning rate (which is not always good), with small profits around 25$ for each trade. The problem ist that suddenkly you can have a 1000$ or more drawdown in your account, because the trader doesn't take losses when necessary. Maybe it can keep it up for a longer time with many small profits, but at one point there will be a even bigger drawdown, that will destroy all the small profits of the last few weeks/months Maybe if the signal provider will have a TOS-Badge in the future, I might change my mind. One other thing I don't like is that in many weeks the signal provider never answered to any questions

The manager is doing an excellent job managing positions with minimal risk, which reflects a strong and disciplined systemic approach. The maximum leverage has always been less than 1, which indicates good risk management. There is no overtrading as well, and with an average trade duration of 100+ days, the strategy simply allows the holdings to compound. The strategy owner is responsive to questions and sends out updates about once a week. Ideal for passive investors.

The strategy is doing well so far. New subscription fee is relatively high not favorable to small capital. However, I am appreciated of the profitable strategy.

deja vu deja vu fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me i joined auto trade of Michael's strategy twice. one about couple years ago and second this time. for once i thought he had oversome his weakness on letting go the STOPs, but again and again just like deer starred at the headlights and freezed. Wiping out triple digits gain on the same YEN trade. if Michael can't decipline his hard STOPs, it will be a loop that he can never get out of it in his trading life cycles like Mr. Livermore i am done hoping for that. ps. i am still on the sub is because he won't refund me the prepaid fees

I think the algo is good but unfortunately folks from Europe cannot trade Tqqq , hence I paid the subscription without doing anything. I tried to trade similar tqqq in LSE but there it was difficult to do the manual trades . The notifications come at the last minute of Market closing and by next day there is some considerable price variance. Appreciate if the strategy caters to non US audience as well. The price is slightly higher and cud be reduced . Appreciate if the strategy manager also communicates frequently to keep the subscribers apprised of the orders

why this guy do not enter stop loses

I guess in the long run you can increase your portfolio,, just need to be patient.

Been consistently making money in what seems to protect profits through good risk management strategies.

I first came across Malik after watching a YouTube interview and decided to join the strategy a little over a month ago. As a full-time day trader, my edge has always been reading intraday price action, but swing trading and holding positions overnight were never my strength. Since joining the WhiteLight strategy, it has helped me build much stronger conviction in holding trades for longer periods. On my first trade, I held the position for over seven days and made close to $3,000. The next two trades only lasted a day or two and resulted in small losses of about $300 to $400 each. On the fourth trade, I was up around $150, not bad in this choppy market. I also appreciate that once alerts are sent, I execute the trades manually through my brokerage account, giving me full control over entries, position sizing, and risk management. Risk management is one of the main reasons I chose this strategy. Winners are structured to be at least 2:1R, while losses are kept small and controlled, making it easier to stay disciplined and consistent. Malik has also been highly responsive to my questions, which adds significant value. Overall, I am very happy with the strategy and recommend it to traders seeking a structured, risk-focused approach to swing trading.

I initially thought this strategy was performing reasonably well. However, after reviewing the trades it executed, I noticed a pattern where it seemed to be buying and selling stocks at a loss. I wasn’t able to understand the rationale behind those decisions at the time. Unfortunately, this led to a loss of nearly $3,000 within about a week. Since I only have limited capital to work with, I decided to exit the strategy to protect my remaining funds.

Excellent strat - uses correct management and doesn't attempt to game the system.

Derrick promoted this strategy, asking his followers on TikTok to subscribe to it. He promised a promotional code, which fell through and didn't work. Then, not only did he change his strategy to Delta Signals Edg3 within a month, but he didn't tell his followers that he changed it. I found out because this strategy didn't align with what he talked about on his substack. When I reached out and told him that I already bought the Singals Edge3 that he told his followers to subscribe to, I didn't hear back. I also reached out to Collective2 hoping they could help, and again, heard nothing. This broke a lot of trust and raises a lot of red flags on his business model. I can't keep paying $149 plus another $49 for the platform every month, especially if I don't know if he'll keep changing his strategy and with the fact that this is already high risk trading. Unless he's willing to reach out to me to help rectify this, I will likely continue to write these kind of reviews because his followers should be aware.

,

all type of stocks some with great potential but also with great risks, not sustainable